What is a Mumbai Sandwich (Bombay Sandwich)?

Oh boy, let me tell you about the Mumbai Sandwich, it’s like a party in your mouth! First, imagine a fluffy slice of white bread, toasted to perfection. Then, picture a layer of tangy green chutney, made with fresh coriander and mint, spread generously over the bread. But wait, there’s more! The sandwich is then filled with spiced potatoes (Aloo masala), slices of onion, juicy tomatoes, beetroots, cheese and yes, even more chutney! This Bombay Sandwich recipe is a burst of flavour and texture. All in all, the Mumbai Sandwich is a sandwich fit for any occasion; a perfect blend of flavours, textures, and spices. So next time you’re feeling adventurous, give it a try and let your taste buds dance with joy!

The Mumbai Sandwich is an essential part of the Indian street food scene. It’s fast, inexpensive, perfectly portable… and it packs a hefty punch of flavour. Everything about this Indian sandwich screams flavour bomb. It’s no wonder India loves this street food sandwich.

What’s special about this Mumbai Sandwich recipe?

You may have guessed, we’re throwing back to some nostalgic 90s TV with this ode to F•R•I•E•N•D•S. The hidden layer of chutney-soaked bread is inspired by The One with Ross’ Sandwich (s.5, ep.9). If you have no idea what I’m talking about, forget everything you just read and make this sandwich anyway. It is not good for my rage 😉

Why add the “Moist Maker”?

While this cheeky addition to this Mumbai Sandwich may not be traditional, it ensures we cram optimal chutney into our sandwich. After all, the green chutney is the best part of any Mumbai Sandwich. A chutney has the power to make or break the whole sandwich experience. A slice of toasted bread is the perfect sponge for the chutney and provides ample moisture (hence the name), without making the sandwich soggy. Perfect.

How to serve The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich

It’s pretty much a meal in itself. Bread and masala potatoes are the custom carbs, veggies and cheese act as secondary belly fillers. Ultimately, you don’t need to serve it with anything. If you really want a side, try some crisps — because who’s gonna tell you how many forms of potatoes are acceptable?

Can I make Mumbai sandwich without a sandwich maker?

Yes. My recipe for The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich is doable in a frying pan, no fancy sandwich press or toastie maker necessary. The results are perfect every single time. However, if you do happen to have a sandwich maker, you can cook this Mumbai Sandwich in the toastie maker or panini press too.

What are the ingredients in a Mumbai sandwich?

To make a Mumbai Sandwich (Bombay Sandwich) recipe, you’ll need:

Bread: Any loaf of sliced bread is fine. I use white because it’s most common. In fact, the cheaper the better. Potato masala: Aloo masala, or potato masala is a filling of spiced, fluffy potatoes. I cook mine with mustard seeds, coriander seeds and turmeric. Green chutney: A thick schmear of green coriander and mint chutney is essential to any Mumbai Sandwich. It’s herby, tart, spicy and zingy. Find my version in the recipe card below. Cheese: I use a medium or mature Cheddar because I love the sharp flavour contrast against the potato filling and chutney. In India, Amul cheese and butter are most commonly used in Mumbai Sandwiches. Onions, tomatoes, beetroots et al: Feel free to experiment with the salads that bulk out the sandwich. Cucumbers, peppers and chillies are all popular additions. Sev: I finish my Mumbai Sandwich with a smattering of Sev (fried chickpea flour noodles) for a boost of crunch.

Troubleshooting: The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich

Pin it for later!

If you like this, you’ll love my Butter Pau Bhaji recipe

	Share this recipe	

The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 64The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 12The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 49The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 32The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 38The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 27The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 40The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 66The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 56The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 53The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 51The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 45The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 10The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 35The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 64The Ultimate Mumbai Sandwich   Sandwiches - 16